Don't be fooled by the name. This tidy operation is no drive-up motor lodge – it's not even on the highway. All eight styles of rooms (some small and economically priced; others larger, with kitchenettes) are a cut above the competition. And you can throw your own party: the extensive grounds harbor a picnic grove with gas barbecues.
It's within walking distance of the beach and the Island Queen ferry to Martha's Vineyard.