If you've got kids and don't take them to Sweet Dreams, they may never forgive you. This independent toy store has a great range of well-curated goodness, from costumes to stuffed animals to board games. Just a few feet away (at 2901 College Ave) is the Sweet Dreams candy store, in case you really want to fulfill little dreams.
The candy store shares hours with the toy store, except it's open a half hour later on Saturday and Sunday.