Owned and run by a warm, hospitable couple, Centro Storico is all about gorgeous produce cooked with love and pride. Trust the staff's suggestions, which might include pasta with fresh sardines or an absolutely sublime calamaro ripieno (stuffed calamari). Desserts are equally pleasing, whether it's a tortino al pistacchio (pistachio tart) or a palate-reviving mint and chocolate sorbet.
Booking ahead on Friday or Saturday nights is recommended.