Finch

This quiet, residential brownstone block seems an unlikely setting for a Michelin-starred restaurant, but the Finch is the real deal, serving modern American cuisine in a stylishly unadorned setting. The menu is perfect for sharing, with cooked-to-perfection mains like bluefish with tomato panzanella and pork belly with peaches. The ample wine list and sophisticated cocktails induce dilemmas, but it's hard to go wrong.