Looking more Santa Fé than tropical, this comfortable inn is one of the island's best options. Eight spacious rooms have French doors and prim decor, with painted ceramic sinks, stenciled walls and soft cotton bedding. Ideal for long stays, suites come with a fully equipped kitchen and living space. The quiet residential area is 10 minutes' walk from the beaches.
Friendly and well managed, the B&B loans kayaks and snorkel gear, and rents golf carts.