A good pick, though the 'Lodge' bit is a gross misnomer. Where else could you find an establishment with an art gallery featuring various paintings and woodcarvings by Bene Tuki, the proprietor? The rooms themselves are nothing outstanding but spruce enough, and the shady garden is a great place to chill out. It's easy walking distance from the action.
Bene's wife, Ana Maria, is also an artist (and children's book author), speaks excellent English and is very knowledgeable about the history of the island. The couple's gallery is worth a visit even if you don't sleep here.